Excerpts of Reviews

Metro Weekly
Potomac Stages
Washington City Paper

Washington Post

Metro Weekly

By Jolene Munch
March 10, 2005

...brought to terrifying life through off-the-charts performances from Karl Miller and Will Rogers...

...Director Paparelli, who makes consistently excellent choices in staging and music, avoids the didactic road of blame and ultimate responsibility. His drama never attempts to excuse the actions of the guilty, but instead offers glimpses into their disconnected realities.

The folks at the United States Theatre Project -- writers Stephen Karam, Sean McNall, and PJ Paparelli and dramaturg Patricia Hersch -- have been corroborating materials collected from interviews, eye-witness reports, survivor testimony, and other research based on the 1999 Columbine High School tragedy for a dramatic transformation that is every bit as intense as the story it explores.

The result is columbinus, a rumbling production and emotional heavyweight that drops small, sad bombs on the heart. You want to intervene, but you are only a spectator witnessing the tragic story of two seemingly typical American high school misfits whose ignored angst led to inconceivable acts of violence toward their fellow classmates and ultimately, themselves. "From a fictional high school in suburban America to Littleton, Colorado," columbinus details the shocking and uncomfortable chain of events of April 20, 1999, when fifteen lives were taken by two teenagers spinning desperately out of control.

Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, the duo that opened fire on their school library, are brought to terrifying life through off-the-charts performances from Karl Miller and Will Rogers. Miller’s enormous instincts fuel his massive boulder of a role, while Rogers’ strength manifests in a realistic portrayal of a sad loner longing to connect with his peers. The physical resemblances, as evident by two yearbook photos of the real Harris and Klebold, is at once unsettling, while the remaining cast of eight delivers authentic, powerful interpretations of high school personas, from Daniel Frith’s closeted "party guy " to Gene Gillette’s smug jock.

columbinus, the Latin phrase for "dove-like" or "peace-like," closely examines the rampant stereotypes and personal identities that form in American high school society, where hormones rage and teenagers, as miniature adults without the experience, are bred among a national culture of apathy and ignorance. The authors do not assert reasons why the events that took place in Colorado were inevitable, but rather how they were inevitable. Director Paparelli, who makes consistently excellent choices in staging and music, avoids the didactic road of blame and ultimate responsibility. His drama never attempts to excuse the actions of the guilty, but instead offers glimpses into their disconnected realities.

While columbinus is proof that some of the best true stories make the best staged dramas, its choking narrative and riveting performances leave the audience grappling with exhausting questions of liability and ethics, fate and destiny. Though the story demonstrates teen angst at its most extreme, parents and teachers and friends continue to ignore warning signs of aggression and intolerance. Told through an artistic medium, columbinus is a tasteful, accurate, and effective review of life in the locker rooms, cafeterias, and courtyards across America. Its most troubling question still remains: How many isolated and lonely Dylans and Erics are out there, struggling right now?

Washington City Paper: (excerpts)

..The two leads are breathtakingly in sync, each feeding the other's fury in delicately shaded ways...

Everyone will have his own moment of recognition at the Round House Theater's alternately electrifying and fiercely mundane evocation of the 1999 bloodbath at Columbine High School. The show is all about how the casual brutality of adolescence contributes to tragedy, and the first half of the show effectively implicates everyone in the audience by demonstrating that fear and pressure can dog not just the punks, goths, and dweebs among us, but also the jocks, nice girls, and BMOC-types who appear to have it all together. Act 2 gives two of Act 1's anonymous kids names--Klebold and Harris--and things become horrifyingly specific.

If the first act's generalized high-school mayhem has the easy grace of choreography, the savage give-and-take in the second feels as precisely calibrated as a stroll on a tightrope. The two leads are breathtakingly in sync, each feeding the other's fury in delicately shaded ways. Dan Covey's hard-edged lighting paints them and their classmates into corners, and Martin Desjardins' sound design, after setting moods with pop songs, finds an efficiently horrifying way to evoke gunfire. Other design elements and the ensemble's harrowing performances combine to the evening's penultimate moments shatteringly effective...

Washington Post:
"Round House's 'columbinus' Limns The Darkest Corners of Adolescence"

By Peter Marks
Washington Post Staff Writer
Wednesday, March 9, 2005; Page C01

...the production, directed with a surefire sense of theatricality by PJ Paparelli and performed by a flawless cast of eight, offers invaluable insight into the primitive psychological warfare that goes on in high school hallways and cafeterias...

...the play is a plea for illuminating the corrosive secrets young people harbor, secrets that should not have led two mixed-up boys and more than a dozen others to early graves.

At the unsettling heart of columbinus, Round House Theatre's ambitious examination of the 1999 bloodbath at Columbine High School, are two harrowing performances. Karl Miller and Will Rogers portray Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, the deluded boys who systematically massacred 12 of their classmates and a teacher. And they are simply riveting.

Let us leave aside for a moment the thorny question of taste, whether there is anything indecent in a meticulous regurgitation of the repulsive thoughts and acts of the two young men who died with their victims on that awful day in Colorado. What Miller and Rogers do in this startling, emotionally charged world premiere on Round House's second stage in Silver Spring is put a cherubic face on horror. It's not the banality of evil they embody; it's the suburbanization of it.

The idea of negative synergy, the notion that this vengeful, tortured pair -- medicated, bullied and ignored -- found in each other the perverse strength to carry out a terrorist assault, suffuses columbinus. (The title is Latin for "dove-like," the authors say.) In one blistering sequence, the boys nourish each other's destructive fury at their keyboards. The flurry of rage-stoked instant messages, projected onto an immense screen behind the stage, gives you an almost clinical sense of how the blending of two lonely and damaged souls could make for one incendiary cocktail.

In its rawest moments, columbinus leads you through the scary catacombs of American adolescence. The play doesn't only deal in effect. It wants you to see the probable cause, and it lays the blame for extreme disaffection among the most vulnerable of the young in a closed social hierarchy that can severely punish those who are weak, or indifferent to its rules. In a first act that posits a landscape of the American high school as more cutthroat than Wall Street, it is the jockocracy that is painted as the most malevolent force. Two actors with imposing muscles blithely taunt and toss around the slighter boys as if there were no possibility for payback. Teenagers are nothing if not shortsighted.

Columbinus, presented in the style of a cautionary documentary, has some shortcomings. The impressionistic first act, which in purposefully generic fashion explores the pressures and identity crises that occur on the cusp of adulthood, is repetitive and overlong. Some incidents, such as the reading aloud in class of an actual essay rife with violent images by Klebold, are searing, even surreally funny. (The disembodied voice of a teacher interrupts to correct Klebold's grammar.) But other scenes merely recall obvious moments from a thousand TV shows -- parents at a dinner table who are too busy to listen, for instance -- or they underline the same point again and again about the dark side of the need to kowtow or conform.

In the more graphic second act, the violence is followed by a predictable earnestness of a sort that calls to mind the perfunctory solemnity of a cable news recap.

Nevertheless, the production, directed with a surefire sense of theatricality by PJ Paparelli and performed by a flawless cast of eight, offers invaluable insight into the primitive psychological warfare that goes on in high school hallways and cafeterias. The script, by a writing team headed by Paparelli, former associate director of Washington's Shakespeare Theatre and now artistic director of the Perseverance Theatre in Juneau, Alaska, is heavily based on research. (Stephen Karam and Sean McNall are credited as co-writers.) The words of Harris and Klebold, as well as court records, statements of Columbine witnesses and interviews with high school students across the country are incorporated into the proceedings. Other conversations are invented.

This technique is borrowed from a burgeoning genre, that of fact-based plays like "The Laramie Project," about the hate-crime murder of a gay man in Wyoming, and "The Exonerated," an evening pieced together from the testimony of death row inmates whose sentences had been commuted or overturned.

The play moves inexorably through a depiction of the everyday agonies of high school to the specific events that fueled the wrath at Columbine. In a series of monologues, the actors, portraying a variety of familiar types (the geek, the goth, the prep) unburden themselves to us. Required to attempt a foul shot in a pickup game of basketball, a non-athlete (James Flanagan) confides his paralyzing fear of humiliation. Frozen in a spotlight -- Dan Covey's lighting is excellent throughout -- the terrified young man is utterly alone.

At this tender age, everyone is locked in solitary confinement with his insecurities. Most kids, columbinus suggests, serve out their sentences, scarred but intact. For a few others, the psychic isolation can have deadly consequences.

Paparelli orchestrates theater technology expertly. JJ Kaczynski's projections are consistently vivid and precisely timed, and Martin Desjardins's sound design fills the space with the ambient noise of adolescence. You'd know that metallic boooop!, signaling the end of a classroom period, anywhere. More piercingly, Desjardins creates a soundscape for gunfire that invades the senses as intimately as blood beating against the eardrum.

Nowhere is the precision more apparent than in the work of the actors playing the killers. Rogers's Klebold is a semisweet counterpoint to Miller's sour Harris. You can imagine Rogers's fumbling character having endured in a marginal niche had he not found Harris. In the most tender moment "columbinus" accords him, Rogers awkwardly tries to reach out to a drama-club girl (Ekatrina Oleska) who has asked him to rehearse the balcony scene from "Romeo and Juliet."

But in this real-life teenage tragedy, it is Harris with whom Klebold seals his suicide pact. They map out their siege in a savage scene in which each, in turn, melts down and recovers. It's the mutual validation they find that leads to disaster. But it's Miller's Harris who lights the fuse. He plays Harris as a clueless volcano, angry at everything and at a loss to understand why. At a poignant turn in the story, a bully knocks his bottle of antidepressants to the ground and he's forced to grope for his pills on his hands and knees, to salvage his one source of stability.

The daily indignities and brutalities to which Harris and Klebold are subjected do not, of course, fully explain their barbaric act. The piece at one point suggests a parallel between Harris and Klebold and the notorious young joy-killers of the 1920s, Leopold and Loeb. The comparison is useful. If, at times, columbinus employs a grievous event for its own purposes, it never lowers itself to the kind of sensationalism that dogged the case of Leopold and Loeb. At its best, the play is a plea for illuminating the corrosive secrets young people harbor, secrets that should not have led two mixed-up boys and more than a dozen others to early graves.



Potomac Stages: (excerpts)

Reviewed March 7
Running time 2:30 - one intermission
General Admission seating
Performed at Round House Theatre, Silver Spring

[PJ Paparelli] brings a sense of intelligence, dramatic intensity and clarity...

[...] Storyline: On April 19, 1999, two seniors at Colorado's Columbine High School went on a shooting spree, killing thirteen of their classmates before committing suicide in the school cafeteria after the bombs they had planted failed to detonate. This theater piece begins by examining what high school life is like in America today and then concentrates on the specific case of Columbine High with an epilogue-style look at the reactions of the family and friends of the shooters and the victims.

PJ Paparelli, who left the Potomac Region to take the position of Artistic Director at Alaska's Perseverance Theatre, is very much in evidence in our region this season. His Romeo and Juliet just closed at the Folger while this new piece which he conceived, co-wrote and directed has now opened at the Round House, Silver Spring. Thus, his reach extends from the classics to the experimental and he brings a sense of intelligence, dramatic intensity and clarity to each. This is the first project of a rather grandly named "United States Theatre Project" which will undertake to develop "epic dramatic experiences that examine a human event, condition or phenomena intrinsic to our social and political fabric as Americans." Quite a goal, that.

The cast of eight young performers is headed by Karl Miller who is well known to local theatergoers (Passing the Love of Women, The Seagull, The Maids) and newcomer Will Rogers as the two disturbed teens at the center of the tragedy. Miller's feral intensity contrasts with Rogers cooler, nearly detached pliability in equally compelling performances. The other six take on multiple roles ranging from classmates to teachers to parents in an effort to recreate the environment from which the horror emerged. They are at their best when working as classmates for their ages lend them to those roles.

It all takes place on a large, steel gray floor painted with the patterns of a basketball court before a giant black board creating a chilling, unwelcoming but somehow awfully familiar space. Sound designer Martin Desjardins provides many audio cues but none as impressive as the hollow echo of each shot during the shooting rampage. The sound of each shot is triggered by either Miller or Rogers pounding on that board, which intensifies the sense of remove between the shooter and the shot while allowing the inner thoughts of the killers to be voiced ("Wow, this is cool!") Paparelli stages the actual shooting session at a hypnotically leisurely pace. No slow-motion gimmickry, just a total absence of any feeling of "let's get this part over with." The pace makes the event all the harder to witness - which, of course, is the whole point.

 

Copyright © 2005-present | Web site design by Crofton Studio